I just repaired the exact same problem with a CR 1604 VLZ PRO. I checked the ribbon cables, the trim pot and op-amp in the preamp section to no avail. In one of the forums I was looking at, someone mentioned the grounding of the pot. As I was running the traces, the plug J2 on the preamp board (JACK PANEL) at pins 29,27, and 25 (the ground pins for the Trim for CH9) on the back side (where the solder points are) you will see a trace from one of the pins to a solder point. The trace is almost at the edge make sure there are no breaks in that trace, if there is, just solder a wire from that pin to the solder point, then your trim should start working. All the above pins mentioned are tied together to the one pin that is connected to that trace.
The board had a little place missing and it was easy to overlook.